History, as I remember it being taught in school, was
always a soporific affair, a dull presentation of events in time. In the
immortal words of the playwright Alan Bennett, ‘..just one f…g thing after
another’.
The reality, of course, was very different and not particularly
pleasant in the 15th and 16th centuries, the period of
the Memoirs under consideration. Life was uncertain, brutal and frequently
short, with the violence and horror of war ever-present. This was especially
true for members and leaders of war-bands involved in constant bids for territorial
acquisitions, raids and plunder.
Zahiru’d-din
Muhammad Babur, one such leader, became ruler of Farghana -- a ‘small country
abounding in grain and fruits’ with ‘seven separate townships’ -- at the tender
age of twelve. In more familiar terms, one could perhaps call him a big zamindar
or minor Raja whose principal occupation during his rather short life of approximately
forty- eight years was the waging of war for plunder and finding a kingdom
to rule. He lost Farghana, conquered Samarkand and lost it, took Kabul and
finally, towards the end of his life and on his fifth raid beyond the Indus,
won the throne of Hind by defeating Ibrahim Lodhi at Panipat in 1526. Babur
died in 1530
The first Mughal combined a strong sword arm with persistent
drive and ambition.
“As there was in me ambition for rule and desire of
conquest, I did not sit at gaze when once or twice an affair had made no progress.”
But Babur was more than just a tough warlord on the
lookout for loot. And it is those other dimensions of the man that add an
intriguing and piquant touch to his terse matter-of-fact prose.
He begins his memoirs with a couple of pages about the
Farghana landscape: the flowing waters, the fruit – nashpati of
Andijan, almonds of Kand-e-badam, apricots and pomegranates of Marghinan, and
the pretty little baghchas (gardens) of Asfara.
One thing that strikes a reader on starting the book
is the way in which language -- or rather words -- migrate with people. Any Hindi
speaker will recognize nashpati, badam, bagcha(bagicha), subz (subzi), darakht,
quasba, tariqa, hamesha (always) and many more Turki words that have a
regular place in Hindi. Languages grow and are enriched by foreign borrowings
and Hindustani is no exception. An occasionally vocalized insistence on ‘purity’
of Hindi -- whatever that may mean -- is retrogression. Still waters stagnate.
In addition to being a war-band leader, Babur wrote
poetry, drank alcohol for much of his life, was strongly influenced by his
grandmother and built gardens with flowing water-courses. The few revealing
passages about his emotional life are short but deserve to be quoted .
Talking about his first marriage when he was about 17 years
of age, he says, “Though I was not ill disposed towards her, yet this being my
first marriage, out of modesty and bashfulness I used to see her once in 10, 15
or 20 days. Later on when even my first inclination did not last my bashfulness
increased. Then my mother Khanim used to send me once a month or every 40 days,
with driving and driving, dunnings and worryings.”
A more modern translation would perhaps be more
effective but the point is adequately conveyed. A rather inhibited and
repressed young man, the first of the Great Mughals!
He also records an infatuation with a pretty boy from
the bazaar!
“I discovered in myself a strange inclination, nay! As
the verse says ‘I maddened and afflicted myself for a boy in the camp bazaar…Until
then I had had no inclination for anyone, indeed of love and desire either by
hearsay or experience. I had not heard I had not talked….”
There is no record of how the matter ended.
Life moved on -- another day, another intrigue,
another battle.
Once established in Hind, Babur writes in detail about
this new land he finds himself in. It’s a brief and quite revealing study of
North India -- zoological, biological and sociological. He regards the mango as
the best fruit of Hindustan and regrets the absence of ‘flowing waters’ despite
the existence of many big rivers and thus builds several gardens with ‘flowing
waters’ in, it appears, Agra, Dholpur and Gwalior and possibly elsewhere too.
As Badshah too, Babur spent a great deal of time
battling opposition, mostly Afghan residues of the Sultanate, and then died
prematurely, aged about 48 years.
Reading the Baburnama can occasionally be a trifle wearisome
--details of early raids, intrigues and political maneuvering get a little
tiresome since one is not familiar with the people, places and events. The
effort to continue , with some judicious skipping, is, however, well worth the
while. The man behind the Badshah’s robes is fascinating, as is the nature of
life in those desperate times.
Happy reading.

This is history as narrated by the one who perhaps unknowingly was creating it. That founders of great empires come across as men consumed by fears, insecurity and human frailties underscores the importance of destiny in the overall scheme of things. There were others too who witnessed the same events from the receiving end and recorded their perspective in the form of folklore. Guru Nanak was one of them. On the way back from Mecca, he reached Saidpur to visit his friend, Lalo. Both were imprisoned and escaped death due to some divine intervention. Guru Nanak wrote four Shabads under the title of Babarvani. One of them describes the conditions in the village- a completely ravaged landscape that did not differentiate between Muslims and Hindus. Attaching the link here in the firm conviction that, more often than not, such accounts provide a more objective, albeit emotionally charged, view of history. Sat Naam Sri Waheguru.
ReplyDeletehttps://gurbanee.blogspot.com/2018/04/jaise-mein-aave-khasam-ki-bani.html
This too-
ReplyDeletehttps://www.nytimes.com/2020/11/30/books/review-babur-nama.html
An evocative review, I must say. The passages about his insecurities as a lover give us an interesting glimpse into the man... something that conventional teaching of history just doesn’t do justice to.
ReplyDeleteGlad you liked it- quite a fascinating memoire
ReplyDelete